Older adults often have problems
sleeping, including difficulty falling asleep, waking up during the
night, and waking up very early in the morning. Daytime sleepiness
is also common, with 20% of Americans living in the community
reporting that they are “usually sleepy in the daytime.”
At least half of older adults living in the community use either
over-the-counter or prescription medications to help them sleep, but
this is a very risky practice.
Sleep problems decrease quality of life
and can lead to injury or other health conditions. Sleep deprivation
in tired individuals can cause mental difficulty, irritability, and
poor judgment, and can lead to accidents. Poor sleepers take more
medications, visit their healthcare providers more often, and rate
their health as poorer than that of other people. Night time
agitation in patients with dementia is a risk factor for placement in
a nursing home. Up to 70% of caregivers report that nighttime
difficulties and sleep disruption played a significant role in their
decision to place an older adult in a nursing home or other
institution.
Causes
of Sleep Problems
The quality of sleep and sleeping
patterns change with age, which reflects both the normal aging
process and any physical or psychiatric conditions. Older adults
also have more sleep troubles with jet lag and shift work.
Several important changes related to
age, both directly and indirectly, include the following:
Going to bed earlier and waking up
earlier the next day
Waking up more often during the
night
Sleeping lighter, with fewer
periods of deep sleep
Needing a longer
time to fall asleep
Napping more during the day
Having rapid
eye-movement (REM) sleep, which is the time of intense dreaming,
occurring earlier in the night
Spending more time in bed
Decreasing ability to sleep
(“sleep decay”)
Having breathing problems (eg,
sleep apnea) or jerking of the legs
Taking sedating medications during
the daytime
Being lonely, inactive, or bored
Research suggests that many sleep
problems in older adults are caused by underlying medical,
psychological, or environmental conditions, rather than by the aging
process itself. However, some primary sleep disorders, such as sleep
apnea and periodic limb movements
during sleep, become more common with age.
In general, sleep problems are
classified as either insomnia or excessive daytime sleepiness.
Insomnia is difficulty falling asleep or staying asleep. It
is usually caused by psychological, medical, or neurologic illness.
Excessive daytime sleepiness is usually caused by a primary
sleep disorder, such as sleep apnea. However, these symptoms can
overlap quite a bit.
Psychological
or social problems
Depression, anxiety, and dementia are
the cause of sleep problems in many older adults. Depression is a
particularly common cause. In fact, sleep disturbance in older
adults who are not currently depressed may be a signal of future
depression. Bereavement is also a common cause of sleep disorders,
primarily because bereavement results in depression. Depressed
people commonly wake up early in the morning, take longer to get to
sleep, and wake up often during the night. Usually, treating the
depression also improves the sleep problems. (See also
Depression.)
Anxiety and stress can also cause
sleeping difficulty. In this case, the problem is usually trouble
falling asleep or waking up early. Trouble falling asleep is often
because of worrying at bedtime (see also Anxiety
Disorders). Worry and stress can also affect the sleep of
caregivers (see also Community-Based
Care and Psychological and Social
Issues).
Dementia and delirium can disturb the
sleep-wake cycle, with waking up often during the night, wandering in
the night, becoming agitated, and sleeping less deeply (see also
Dementia and Delirium).
Dementia commonly causes disturbances in
the sleep-wake cycle, resulting in sleeping in the daytime
and being awake during the night.
Lifestyle changes also
contribute to sleep problems. For example, older adults may spend
more time in bed because of less social and physical activity and a
feeling that there is no reason to get up. Older adults in hospitals
or nursing homes may have trouble sleeping because of conditions in
the environment, such as temperature, noise, and bright lighting.
Drug
and alcohol dependency
Drug and alcohol use account for
perhaps 10%–15% of cases of insomnia (see also Substance
Abuse). Sleeping pills and other drugs with a sedative
effect are often a concern. Chronic use of sedatives may result in
only light, short periods of sleep. It may also lead to tolerance,
or “getting used to” a drug, so that higher and higher
doses are needed. If the sedatives are then suddenly stopped,
insomnia may “rebound,” and the person may start taking
sedatives again in a vicious cycle.
Alcohol abuse is often associated with
shorter periods of lighter sleep. In addition, some people think
that using alcohol will help sleeping difficulties, but it actually
makes the problem worse. Although alcohol may cause drowsiness
initially, it interrupts sleep later in the night.
Medical
problems
Many cases of insomnia are due to
underlying medical problems, including the following:
Pain from arthritis and other
conditions
Skin sensations (eg, burning,
prickling, tickling, or tingling) from nerve problems
Coughing or difficulty breathing
Heartburn from gastroesophageal
reflux disease
Urination during the night
Sleep can also be affected by
medications (eg, diuretics [“water pills”],
bronchodilators) and by drinking caffeine or smoking close to
bedtime. Some drugs for depression, Parkinson’s disease, or
high blood pressure can bring on nightmares, resulting in sleep
problems. Medications that are being taken for other conditions that
have sedative effects (eg, some antidepressants) should be taken at
bedtime if possible. Your healthcare provider or pharmacist can
provide advice on when to take or avoid medications.
Disturbances
in the sleep-wake cycle
Our bodies follow a natural rhythm of
sleeping and awakening. This rhythm can be interrupted temporarily
(eg, by jet lag), but in some people, this disrupted sleep becomes a
regular pattern. In some cases, the cycle can become very irregular
or out of “synch” (eg, in dementia). However, the most
common problem in older adults is falling asleep early and waking up
early. Falling asleep late and waking up late is also very common in
older adults.
Sleep
apnea
In sleep apnea, breathing slows down or
stops briefly every so often throughout the night during sleep.
People with sleep apnea often wake up many times during the night
because of blocked breathing, so they suffer from excessive daytime
sleepiness. They may also have morning headaches, changes in
personality, poor memory, confusion, and irritability. These people
are typically unaware that they are waking up often during the night.
A bed partner may report loud snoring or choking sounds during
sleep.
Sleep apnea is relatively common among
older adults, more so in men than in women. It also becomes more
common as we get older. Most people referred to sleep centers for
evaluation of daytime sleepiness (70%) have sleep apnea. In some,
people, sleep apnea is severe and needs treatment.
The most important risk factor for
sleep apnea is obesity and having a thick neck. Alcoholism is also
an important risk factor. There also may be a link between sleep
apnea and dementia (eg, Alzheimer’s disease), but this is
currently being researched.
Sleep apnea can be diagnosed for
certain only in a sleep laboratory, where breathing and other bodily
functions are monitored while a person is sleeping. Treatments for
sleep apnea include the following:
weight loss
reducing alcohol consumption
surgical procedures involving the
nasal passages, the back of the mouth, and the throat
“continuous positive airway
pressure” (CPAP), which involves wearing a mask that provides
air under pressure to counteract the breathing obstruction seen in
sleep apnea; it is not known if older adults can tolerate this
procedure as well as younger people.
Periodic limb movements during sleep
Some people have problems with periodic
uncontrolled spasms in their legs during the night. The legs move
every 20–40 seconds, which can last a few hours or much of the
night. This problem increases with age, so it is more common among
older adults. Some people who suffer from periodic limb movements
may be unaware of it.
“Restless legs syndrome” is
a similar disorder that produces uncontrollable urges to move the
legs at night. These symptoms occur while the person is awake and
can also involve the arms. Usually, people have leg discomfort at
night or have trouble falling asleep. There may be a family history
of this condition and, in some cases, an underlying medical disorder
(eg, anemia, kidney disease, or a nervous system disorder). Like
periodic limb movements, restless legs syndrome becomes more common
with age. Many people with restless legs also have periodic limb
movements.
These two related problems can be
debilitating because of having trouble falling asleep and waking up
several times during the night. Sufferers are usually sleepy during
the day and may be confused and irritable because of lack of sleep.
REM sleep behavior disorder
During rapid eye-movement (REM) sleep,
the brain is very active and people have vivid dreams. Some people
also have muscular activity during this time that can result in sleep
behaviors such as trying to respond to or act out a vivid dream.
These behaviors may cause injury to the dreamer or to their bed
partner. REM sleep behavior disorder may appear suddenly or become a
chronic problem. It is more common in older men, and it may tend to
run in families.
Temporary REM sleep behavior disorder
can be caused by drug or alcohol intoxication or withdrawal. Chronic
REM sleep behavior disorder usually has no known cause, although
sometimes it is associated with conditions that result in a
neurologic problem (eg, drug intoxication, tumor, blood vessel
problem, infection, degenerative disorder, or trauma).
The sleeping environment must be made
safe. The following measures are helpful:
remove dangerous objects from the
bedroom
put cushions on the floor around
the bed
protect windows
put the mattress on the floor
Sleep
Disturbances in the Hospital or Nursing Home
Insomnia is common while in the
hospital. Sleep-related breathing disorders (eg, sleep apnea) may be
particularly common in adults hospitalized for heart disease or
stroke. People in nursing homes also frequently have sleep problems,
including having their sleep interrupted and waking up often during
the night. Usually, several factors are involved, including illness,
medications, change from usual nighttime routines at home,
inactivity, and a too brightly lit or noisy environment. Not being
exposed to bright light during the day may also be a factor.
Sleeping pills or other sedatives are
often used for sleep problems in hospitals or nursing homes, but can
create other problems themselves. In some studies, non-drug
treatments improved sleep in institutional settings, and they may
reduce the chances of becoming delirious in the hospital.
Evaluation
and Assessment for Sleep Disorders
You should discuss sleep problems with
your healthcare provider. Many people assume that sleep problems are
an unavoidable part of aging and don’t mention them to their
healthcare provider. Many healthcare providers frequently screen for
unreported sleep problems by asking the following types of questions:
Are you satisfied with your sleep?
Does sleep or fatigue interfere
with your daytime activities?
Does your bed partner complain of
unusual behavior during sleep, such as snoring, interrupted
breathing, or leg movements?
Let your healthcare
provider know how long sleep problems have been present and whether
you’ve been under additional stress, have leg twitching, etc.
Temporary disturbances lasting 2–3 weeks are usually caused by
a specific situation (eg, shift work, worry about finances, etc).
Problems that last longer than a month indicate a more serious,
underlying medical or psychiatric condition, and a more detailed
evaluation is needed.
When you have an office evaluation for
persistent sleep problems, your sleep partner should come with you to
also provide information because you may not be aware of certain
symptoms. Keeping a “sleep log” can be helpful. Sleep
logs should include information on the quality of your sleep for a
2-week period. The log can be kept by you, your bed partner, or a
caregiver. Every morning, the following information about the last
24 hours should be entered in your sleep log:
Time spent in bed
Estimated amount of sleep
Number of times woke up during the
night
The time of waking up in the
morning
Any symptoms while sleeping (eg,
heavy snoring, leg twitching, or other movements)
Your healthcare provider will perform a
physical examination, focusing on information you provided about your
sleep history. For example, painful joints suggest evaluation for
arthritis, while bed wetting would be followed by evaluating for
diabetes or for heart, kidney, or prostate problems. Your healthcare
provider will also likely check your mental functions. Laboratory
testing may be needed, depending on the results of the history and
physical examination.
In some cases, your healthcare provider
will refer you to a sleep laboratory for specialized testing. One
particularly useful test called polysomnography can identify specific
sleep disorders, such as sleep apnea, periodic limb movement
disorder, or other unusual behaviors during sleep. Various portable
devices are being developed for measuring nighttime activity or
breathing difficulties at home.
Management
of Sleep Problems
Although occasional
sleeping difficulties may be an unavoidable consequence of getting
older, there are ways to improve overall sleep quality. For example,
sticking to a regular sleep-wake schedule and limiting time in bed to
no more than 7 or 8 hours a night can help counteract both the
tendency to nap during the day and a more broken up sleep-wake
pattern. Daytime naps because of boredom or medications often can be
corrected by increasing physical activity or changing medication(s).
Ways
to Improve Sleep Quality
Get up at the same
time every day.
Go to bed at the
same time every day, unless you do not feel sleepy.
Keep napping to a
minimum or not at all.
Exercise every
day, but not immediately before bedtime.
Do not read or
watch television in bed, except right before going to sleep.
Relax mentally
before going to sleep. Do not use bedtime as worry time.
Avoid heavy meals
at bedtime. If you are hungry, have a light snack, but snacks
should be avoided in certain medical conditions (eg, nighttime
heartburn).
Limit or eliminate
alcohol, caffeine, and nicotine, especially before bedtime.
Wind down before
bedtime, and keep a routine for getting ready to go to bed (eg,
washing up, going to the bathroom).
Control your
environment during the night, eg, comfortable temperature, quiet,
and darkness.
Try a familiar
background noise (eg, a fan or other “white noise”
machine).
Wear comfortable
pajamas.
If you haven’t
fallen asleep within 30 minutes, get out of bed and do something
soothing (eg, listen to soft music or do some light reading). Avoid
turning on bright lights.
Get adequate
exposure to bright light during the day.
The causes of sleep problems should be
corrected whenever possible. Primary sleep disorders (eg, sleep
apnea) or medical conditions that lead to sleep problems should be
treated. Nighttime pain can be treated with appropriate pain
relievers. Clinical depression can be treated with appropriate
antidepressant drugs, counseling, or other therapies. If sleep
problems are related to medications, changing the type of drug or the
dosage can be helpful. However, you should never start or stop
taking medications without first consulting your healthcare provider.
Drug
treatments
There are drugs available for
short-term use to help people fall asleep, but no drugs have been
shown to improve performance or mental alertness the next day, so it
is not clear that sedation from these drugs has the same restorative
effects as natural sleep. Even when used for a short term, there is
reason to be cautious: many of these drugs can leave you groggy the
next day, and they have been shown to increase the chances of falling
and breaking a hip. Short-acting medications are usually prescribed
for people who have trouble falling asleep, while medications that
last longer are usually prescribed for people who have trouble
staying asleep. In addition to any drug treatment, techniques to
improve sleep quality, such as limiting napping during the day and
avoiding alcohol, are recommended.
Sedatives are not generally used to
treat chronic insomnia, because long-term use can lead to
complications such as increased risk of confusion, falling, and
fractures in older adults. Some drugs (eg, benzodiazepines) can lead
to dependence or mental difficulties if taken for a long time.
Research also suggests that long-term use of sleeping pills is
associated with increased illness and early death. In fact, it has
been suggested that the nightly use of prescription sleeping pills is
a health hazard similar to smoking one to two packs of cigarettes per
day.
Certain drugs can be effective for
specific sleep disorders. For example, clonazepam can be highly
effective for treating REM sleep behavior disorder, with little
evidence of complications with long-term treatment. Older adults
with periodic limb movement disorder or restless leg syndrome may
benefit from drugs called “dopamine agonists.”
Over-the-counter
(OTC) sleep aids
Nearly half of older adults use OTC
sleeping pills. The most commonly used products include
antihistamines that cause sedation, acetaminophen preparations (with
or without antihistamines), alcohol, and melatonin. Antihistamines
such as diphenhydramine are common ingredients in both OTC sleeping
pills and nighttime pain relievers intended to help someone sleep.
Diphenhydramine is generally not recommended for older adults because
it can have several side effects, including delirium, trouble
urinating, and constipation. In addition, tolerance develops to its
sedating effects after several weeks, which means that it becomes
less effective at improving sleep.
Alcohol is also not recommended as a
sleep aid. Although it causes some initial drowsiness, it can
interfere with sleep later in the night and may actually worsen
sleeping difficulties.
Some sleep aids contain natural
products, such as melatonin or valerian (see also
Complementary and Alternative Medicine).
Research evidence is mixed regarding the effectiveness of these
products, with some studies reporting benefits and other studies
reporting none. Also, valerian contains several different chemicals,
so there is the possibility of a number of side effects.
Behavioral
treatments
Several behavioral treatments can
effectively improve sleep quality without having to use drugs.
Behavioral treatments can provide reliable and lasting benefits for
people with insomnia. Correcting poor sleep habits by using the
following measures seems to be especially helpful among older adults
with insomnia:
Go to bed only
when sleepy.
Do not use the bed
for eating or watching television.
Get out of bed if
unable to fall asleep, and go back to bed only when sleepy.
Get up at the same
time each morning.
Do not take naps
during the day.
Keep a sleep log
for 2 weeks to determine average total daily sleep time. Then stay
in bed only that amount of time plus 15 minutes. Gradually increase
the time allowed in bed as sleep improves.
Identifying and changing any inaccurate
beliefs and attitudes about sleep can also be helpful. This includes
learning the difference between changes in sleep that are normal with
increased age and changes that may indicate a medical condition may
be developing. Learning relaxation techniques to recognize and
relieve tension and anxiety (eg, tensing and relaxing muscle groups,
or biofeedback techniques) are more effective for younger people than
for older adults.
Other
treatments
In some research studies, older adults
with insomnia have benefited from exposure to bright light (either
natural sunlight or an artificial light source). Light treatment was
helpful using light of different intensities, for different lengths
of time, and at different times during the day. Light exposure
during the evening seems to be particularly useful in older adults
who fall asleep early and wake up early. Difficulty staying asleep
has been successfully treated by being exposed to bright light for 2
hours (similar to the amount of outdoor light at mid-day). Being
exposed to bright light even for a short time in the morning has
improved sleep in some healthy older adults. It is important to
remember that light therapy should be administered only by trained
professionals. You should never stare at the sun or other bright
light, because this can cause vision problems.
Taking a bath before going to bed can
improve the quality of sleep in older adults, perhaps because bathing
increases body temperature. A moderate amount of exercise also
improves sleep in healthy, inactive people aged 50 and older.
However, strenuous exercise should not be done immediately before
bedtime.
|